For most of its rise, Google treated the open web as a birthright. Information wanted to be found, links wanted to be followed, and the company's job was simply to be the best door in. Then it walked into the one market where the door came with a lock, a guard, and a list of things you were not allowed to say. China would become the hardest test yet of Google's founding promise — the place where "don't be evil" stopped being a slogan and started being a decision with no clean answer.
The bargain
Google had offered a Chinese-language version of google.com since September 2000, but the site sat on the far side of the Great Firewall — slow, throttled, and periodically blocked. To actually compete with the homegrown giant Baidu, Google needed servers and a license inside the country. In July 2005 it hired Kai-Fu Lee, a marquee ex-Microsoft executive, to build a Beijing engineering office and lead the push.
The catch was written into the law: a search engine operating on Chinese soil had to filter its results. On 26 January 2006, Google launched google.cn — and for the first time in its history, it deliberately hid pages from users. Searches for "Tiananmen," "Falun Gong," or "Dalai Lama" returned scrubbed lists, with a small disclosure noting that some results had been removed to comply with local law. Google's reasoning was coldly utilitarian: a censored Google that Chinese users could actually reach was, it argued, better than a free Google they mostly couldn't. Co-founder Sergey Brin, who spent his early childhood in the Soviet Union, admitted he was deeply uneasy with the compromise. When U.S. lawmakers hauled American tech firms before Congress in early 2006 to answer for cooperating with Chinese censorship, the criticism stung precisely because it was aimed at a company that had built its brand on openness.
Four years, and a share that never came
The bargain never fully paid off. Baidu understood the local market, the language, and the regulators far better, and Google spent four years as the well-funded runner-up. Its search share peaked at roughly 36% in August 2009 — respectable anywhere else, but a distant second at home. Friction mounted: YouTube was blocked in March 2009 over footage from Tibet, and other services flickered on and off at the government's discretion. That September, Kai-Fu Lee abruptly departed to start his own venture fund, and the mood inside Google China darkened.
Then came the attack. Beginning in mid-2009 and running through December, a sophisticated intrusion later dubbed Operation Aurora — named by McAfee researcher Dmitri Alperovitch after a string found in the malware — penetrated Google and more than twenty other companies, including Adobe, Juniper, and Rackspace. Investigators concluded the campaign originated in China and reached for the crown jewels: source-code repositories, and the Gmail accounts of Chinese human-rights activists. For Google, this was no longer an abstract debate about filtered links. It was a break-in.
The exit
On 12 January 2010, Chief Legal Officer David Drummond published a blog post titled "A New Approach to China." Google announced it was no longer willing to censor google.cn and was prepared to shut its Chinese operations entirely if it couldn't run an uncensored search engine "within the law, if at all." U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton weighed in within hours, condemning the attacks. It was an extraordinary move: a corporation publicly picking a fight with a government over free expression, and betting a billion-user market on principle.
The resolution was quieter than the declaration. On 22 March 2010, rather than flip a censorship switch back on, Google redirected mainland traffic from google.cn to google.com.hk — its Hong Kong site, which sat outside most mainland censorship rules and returned unfiltered results. It was a legal sidestep dressed as a retreat: Google could tell itself it had stopped censoring, while Beijing could let the Firewall do the filtering instead. Members of the public left flowers at Google's Beijing headquarters, an "illegal flower tribute" to a search engine. The Great Firewall quietly absorbed the rest. Within a few years Google's mainland search share collapsed toward the low single digits, and the company that had promised to organize the world's information found that one-fifth of the world's people were, once again, out of reach.
Google had chosen its conscience over its market — and lost the market. But the fight revealed something the company preferred to keep hidden: to serve billions of queries and survive nation-state attacks, Google had quietly become one of the largest builders of computers on Earth. Next time: inside the secret data-center empire behind the search box.
Comments
Post a Comment