Most companies bury their values in a laminated poster nobody reads. Google's most famous value started as graffiti. Sometime in 1999, in the cramped early offices, an engineer named Amit Patel took a marker to a whiteboard and wrote three words that would follow the company for the next two decades: Don't be evil. He kept rewriting it. People kept not erasing it. And a throwaway line slowly hardened into a creed.
It's easy, from here, to read those words cynically. But to understand early Google, you have to take them seriously — because for a while, a lot of the people inside the building did.
Three words, and who really said them
The origin story has two claimants, and both are probably true. Patel is credited with the whiteboard version around 1999. The more official adoption came at a corporate-values meeting a year or two later, when Paul Buchheit — the engineer who would go on to create Gmail — blurted out “Don't be evil” as a catch-all for everything the others were trying to articulate in paragraphs.
Buchheit later explained the appeal with disarming honesty. He wanted “something that, once you put it in there, would be hard to take out.” And he admitted it was “a bit of a jab” at competitors who, in Google's view, were quietly exploiting their own users. It was a value statement and a competitive taunt rolled into one — which is a very Google thing to be.
The phrase captured something specific about the culture Larry Page and Sergey Brin were building. This was a company run by engineers who distrusted marketing, distrusted anything that put money ahead of the answer, and genuinely believed the quality of a search result was a kind of moral question. “Don't be evil” wasn't about grand ethics. It was mostly about one concrete promise: we will not sell you a worse answer because someone paid us to.
A culture built to argue
The motto didn't exist in a vacuum. It grew out of a workplace that was deliberately, almost aggressively, un-corporate. Early Google looked less like a business and more like a graduate lab that had wandered off campus — lava lamps, exercise balls, dogs underfoot, and engineers who would happily tell a founder his idea was wrong.
That last part mattered most. Page and Brin had spent their Stanford years disagreeing about nearly everything, and they wired that habit into the company. Decisions were supposed to be won on the merits, not by seniority. To keep it that way, they instituted the ritual that would define Google's internal life for years: TGIF, a company-wide meeting where anyone could stand up and ask the founders anything — product plans, strange decisions, uncomfortable questions — and expect a real answer.
Then there was the food. In 1999, Google hired its first chef, Charlie Ayers, who had previously cooked for the Grateful Dead. Free gourmet meals weren't a perk in the modern, cynical “keep them at their desks” sense — at least not yet. They were a signal: stay, eat together, talk, and the good ideas will fall out of the conversation. Silicon Valley has been copying the cafeteria ever since, usually missing the point.
The famous 20 percent
If one policy embodied “Don't be evil” as a working philosophy, it was 20% time — the idea that engineers could spend a fifth of their week on whatever project they thought Google should be doing, whether or not anyone had asked for it. It was trust as infrastructure. And it paid off in ways the balance sheet never predicted: Gmail, Google News, and AdSense all trace their roots to someone's side project.
Taken together, the pieces formed a coherent bet. Hire brilliant people, feed them, let them argue with you, give them room to chase their own ideas, and hold the whole thing to a three-word standard simple enough to fit on a whiteboard. For a company still small enough to fit in a few rooms, it worked astonishingly well.
The long, awkward afterlife
Of course, mottos are easier to keep when you're small. As Google grew into a public company, then a global one, “Don't be evil” became less a private guardrail and more a public promissory note — one critics would wave back at the company every time it did something they didn't like.
In 2004, Page and Brin put it in writing for the world, enshrining the phrase in their IPO founders' letter with a line that reads almost quaint today: they'd rather do good “even if we forgo some short term gains.” Even Eric Schmidt, the seasoned executive brought in to run the place, initially called it “the stupidest rule ever” — until he watched an engineer kill a profitable ad product simply by invoking it in a meeting. The rule, it turned out, had teeth.
The slow fade came later. When Google reorganized under Alphabet in 2015, the new parent's code of conduct swapped in a blander “Do the right thing.” And in 2018, Google quietly removed “Don't be evil” from the preface of its own code, leaving it stranded in the final sentence. The words never fully disappeared — but they stopped being the headline.
None of that had happened yet in 1999. Back then it was just three words on a whiteboard, in a company that still had to answer a far more pressing question: how do you turn the world's best search engine into an actual business? Two of Silicon Valley's fiercest rivals were about to help them try.
Next time — Part 6: Kleiner + Sequoia, and the improbable feat of getting two arch-rival venture firms to fund the same startup.
Comments
Post a Comment